Best PrizePicks Alternatives: Underdog, Sleeper & Other DFS Apps Like PrizePicks

Anyone with a DFS pick’em bone in their body has given PrizePicks a try. And if you’re a regular player, there’s a good chance PrizePicks is your go-to. Maybe the whole mainstream thing has gotten stale for you, though. Maybe you want the opportunity for more picks, more from new-user bonuses, more contest types. Or maybe PrizePicks isn’t available in your state at all. Well, that’s why we’re here to help at Stokastic; we have the lowdown on the best PrizePicks alternatives and how these apps can tickle your fantasy fancy in new and unique ways. Here we will cover the three best pick’em-style DFS apps like PrizePicks and also one peer-to-peer option.

Stokastic is bringing its top-tier projections to the pick’em game! With the Pick’em package, you’ll get access to the PrizePicks Optimizer, Underdog Optimizer and DraftKings Pick6 Optimizer, allowing you to create +EV entries with just a few clicks. Whether you’re a pick’em pro or just starting out, Stokastic’s Pick’em tools and data give you an unbeatable edge.

For a limited time, use promo code PICKEM25 to get 25% off Stokastic’s Pick’em Tools for PrizePicks, Underdog and DraftKings Pick6!

Grab this offer before the 2024 NFL season kicks off!

Best DFS Apps Like PrizePicks: Pick’em App Alternatives

If you some more tips on how to use the Post-Contest Simulator to improve your lineup study process, Steve Buzzard has a great guide here on how to maximize your lessons learned from the Sims! Check it out HERE.

Underdog Fantasy

How Underdog Is Similar to PrizePicks

In the most basic of ways, Underdog has a lot in common with PrizePicks. Most notable is the general function of both apps’ pick’em contests: They require you to choose a player and a statistic and choose if that player will go for more or less than that statistic. The more picks you get right, the greater your payout. They both also have “Flex” plays that allow you to miss a pick (or, in Underdog’s Pick8, multiple picks) and still get some payout, with the tradeoff being that you get less money for a perfect entry.

Payout multipliers are pretty close for the two sites, but there are some differences both slight and major, which we will break down in more detail below.

The two apps largely have the same available statistics to play (points, yards, etc.) and most of the same sports, though PrizePicks offers a few more niche sports than Underdog does. Additionally, PrizePicks and Underdog both have mobile and desktop platforms, which is becoming more rare as newer DFS apps choose to forgo the computer version and focus solely on the app.

More recently, with states debating legality of pick’em games, PrizePicks and Underdog have each released their own peer-to-peer contest that residents of non-active states can play. Underdog’s is called “Pick’em Champions” and PrizePicks’ is “Pick ‘Em Arena.” These two contests function similarly as well.

How Underdog Is Different from PrizePicks

The first big difference between PrizePicks and Underdog is the layout. Underdog presents all of a player’s projections under one card, which takes up a lot of space on the screen but also makes it easy to choose multiple stats for one player. PrizePicks has the more traditional set up of sorting by stat and then listing the players that have a projection in that category. Underdog also has “Rivals” picks where you put players head-to-head to determine which will get more of a statistic. PrizePicks has no similar head-to-head contest.

Underdog’s payout structure also differs quite significantly in some ways from PrizePicks, especially following Underdog’s launch of Pick8 — a Flex entry that allows you to make up to eight picks. Previously the highest number of picks you could make was five. PrizePicks still caps their picks at four for a Power Play and six for a Flex Play. Here is the full payout structure for both entry formats on each app:

Standard Entries

You’ll notice that Underdog has a higher maximum for picks (five instead of four) and also 6x for three correct picks compared to 5x for PrizePicks.

Flex/Insured Entries

There is also the matter of Underdog having the No. 1 Best Ball product in the world. You can move between Best Ball teams and drafts in the same app where you play pick’em, making Underdog more of a one-stop shop than PrizePicks can offer, as they only have pick’em contests.

Lastly, though both sites offer signup bonuses for new users, they are pretty different: PrizePicks’ is a $50 bonus on your first $5 play, whereas Underdog’s is a 50% match up to $1,000. That means you can get the higher deposit match from Underdog, but depositing $100 will only get you $150 total, while PrizePicks will put up $50 no questions asked.

Sleeper Fantasy

How Sleeper Is Similar to PrizePicks

Like Underdog, Sleeper offer’s pick’em-style fantasy much in the same vein of PrizePicks. You select the players, their statistic you want to play and whether you think they will get more or less. More picks right equal more money. Sleeper too has a peer-to-peer game, this one called Sleeper PicksVS, which is also similar to Underdog’s.

That is kind of where the similarities end in the pick’em space, though, which we will get to below.

There are two other things that PrizePicks and Sleeper have in common: One, the layout, and two, the deposit match — both areas where Underdog and PrizePicks differed. Sleeper keeps the players in neat cards mostly sorted by game or statistic, just like PrizePicks. The color schemes are different (and I personally prefer Sleeper’s appearance), but functionally these apps are the same format.

As for the deposit bonus, Sleeper’s is a 100% match up to $100, while PrizePicks’ is the aforementioned “play $5 for $50” deal.

How Sleeper Is Different from PrizePicks

First of all, Sleeper was designed as a social app, and that shows in various ways. For one, the social features are much more prominently displayed, and chats with other users are never more than a click away. Sleeper also has customizable season-long leagues that offer both freedom to build your own fantasy experience and further social interaction with leaguemates.

The area where Sleeper differs most, however, is with the payout formats in pick’em. Unlike PrizePicks (and most pick’em apps), which has the fixed multipliers as listed above, Sleeper’s multipliers vary based on data and public action on each side of a projection. That makes the contest a bit trickier since the multipliers are always moving in an attempt to keep picks coming on both the more and the less. On top of that, Sleeper allows up to eight picks and 100x in payouts if you hit all eight.

Now, Sleeper has a “Flex” play of sorts, called a “Combo” play, but it too has variable multipliers. Your payouts for getting zero, one or two wrong stack up based on the multipliers of each individual play rather than a fixed amount.

All in all, Sleeper offers a more comprehensive experience and more difficult challenge for users who want to really test their sports knowledge. On the other hand, PrizePicks is a bit more advantageous financially to the user but with fewer features.

Vivid Picks

How Vivid Is Similar to PrizePicks

Again, the core principles with Vivid Picks are pretty aligned with PrizePicks. It is a pick’em app where you choose if a player will go for more or less than a statistic. That’s it. That app is laid out similarly, the picks are made in the same way and the payouts are relatively close. That is the end of the similarities, however.

How Vivid Is Different from PrizePicks

Vivid Picks is quite close to Underdog in terms of its pick’em contest and app. Format-wise, the player cards on Vivid also take up a lot of the screen because they opt to include all player projections in each card, but it is a little sleeker because Vivid has the statistics presented horizontally in a scrolling bar. Additionally, Vivid allows up to 10 picks in an entry, more than most other DFS apps.

Another huge difference is Vivid not having fixed multipliers. However, they are not like Sleeper’s that assign fluctuating multipliers to individual players. Rather, Vivid’s multipliers vary by sport and slate. There is no set table of multipliers like PrizePicks and Underdog have. That said, you can win up to 250x with Vivid, much higher than PrizePicks’ 25x.

Vivid also has a format called “Versus” where two players are put head-to-head in a statistical category, but the two sides are presented similarly to point spread. For example, if an NBA head-to-head is a star player versus a role player and the category in question is points, the role player may be listed as (+8.5), meaning the star has to score at least 9 points more than the role player. This is another fun wrinkle Vivid has thrown into traditional pick’em.

There is one other major difference: The social aspect. Vivid has a social feed where you can follow other users and/or view users you don’t follow and see what picks they made. If you like their entry, you can copy it and submit the same one yourself. Since Vivid contests are against the house, there isn’t really any downside to duplicating picks with another user.

And finally, Vivid’s new-user promo is a much more lucrative maximum deposit match than any other: Up to $300.

DraftKings Pick6

Now we’re exploring peer-to-peer apps in DraftKings Pick6 and PrizePicks Pick ‘Em Arena, which pit you against other users to win money. These are usually available in states where traditional pick’em contests are not legally allowed.

How Pick6 Similar to PrizePicks Arena

Functionally, peer-to-peer contests for Pick6 and Pick ‘Em Arena are the same: You select players and whether they will go for more or less than a statistical projection, and you try to get more correct than other players in your group. The way that bears out, however, is pretty different, which we will detail below.

The apps are also pretty similar in terms of layout and function, with most differences being minor and not really giving one a proverbial “edge” over another. It’s once we explore the minutia of the app, however, that we see how DraftKings Pick6 is an alternative to PrizePicks, not merely a copy of it.

How Pick6 Is Different from PrizePicks Arena

The biggest difference is Pick ‘Em Arena having a much more fixed payout system. You are separated into groups based on the number of picks in your entry, and if you get all your picks right, your payouts are the same no matter how others in your group did: 10x for 4-for-4, 5x for 3-for-3 and 3x for 2-for-2. If no one in the group hits all their picks, the top entry gets 10x, and multiple winners split that 10x in the likely event of a tie.

DraftKings Pick6 does not have fixed multipliers; instead the prize pool is set and winnings are split whether there are perfect entries or not. Because the prize pools are not consistent across slates, it can be tough to know how much you stand to win in a contest. Pick6 does give an estimated payout, however.

All in all, Pick6 has a higher maximum payout amount because of this, but typically the payouts are higher from Pick ‘Em Arena because of the automatic 10x for perfect entries.

Pick6 is also pretty much the only DFS app with a “play and get” new-user offer rather than a deposit match. With DraftKings Pick6, you can get $50 in Pick6 Credits with your first $5 play; PrizePicks’ promo is a 100% match up to $100. The “play and get” is a little more generous because it’s an automatic $50 with your first play, whereas with a deposit match you need to deposit at least $50 real money to get the same number of bonus credits.

Conclusion: What Are the Best Apps Like PrizePicks?

PrizePicks is the top name in the DFS pick’em space, no doubt about it. But you have other options if PrizePicks isn’t doing it for you, and many of these alternatives to PrizePicks do some things better than PrizePicks does. Underdog and Sleeper have season-long fantasy. Vivid has more robust multipliers for winnings and different pick’em types. Pick6 has better new-user offers and a unique payout system.

Any one of these could be the difference between you liking an app like PrizePicks more than PrizePicks itself. Check them out, and when you do, make sure you sign up with one of our DFS promo codes to make sure you’re taking advantage of new-user offers! Nonetheless, hopefully you found at least one of our best PrizePicks alternatives useful!